Available nowWhittier
2359 North Lafayette Street, Unit 3
Denver · 1 bd · 1 ba · 500 sq ft
$1,149a month
Cats and dogs
Denver property management, locally owned
Enjoy your time. Leave the rental to us.
Leasing, resident screening, rent collection, 24/7 maintenance, and owner accounting for rental homes across the Denver metro. Month-to-month agreement. No hidden fees.
- Google rating from 48 reviews
- 4.9
- BBB rating, accredited since 2023
- A+
- Years of combined experience
- 30+
Start here
Three ways in. One team on the other side.
I own a rental
Hand us the keys. We price it, lease it, collect the rent, and handle the 2 AM calls.
I rent from My Haven
Pay rent, request a repair, or reach us after hours. Holly picks up every time.
I'm looking for a home
15 homes open right now across the metro, from $1,149 a month.
For owners
Your rental, run like it's ours.
One point of contact who knows your home, a month-to-month agreement, and fees you can read in one breath. You stay because it works, not because a contract says so.
4315 Bryant St, Sunnyside. A My Haven home, open for lease now.
- 01
Pricing that fills the home
A rental analysis built on current Denver comps and our own leasing data, so the rent is right on day one and the home doesn't sit.
- 02
Marketing on 20+ rental sites
Professional photos and video, syndicated to Zillow and the rest, with self-guided tours for vacant homes so prospects can see it the day they find it.
- 03
Screening you can stand behind
Credit, verified income, debt-to-income, eviction records, criminal history, and landlord references, applied the same way to every applicant.
- 04
Rent in your account every month
Residents pay online. We reconcile by the 10th and disburse once payments clear, typically around the 12th.
- 05
Maintenance, day and night
Repairs go to vetted, insured vendors at negotiated prices. Every completed work order gets a resident survey.
- 06
Statements you can read
Monthly statements, invoices, and receipts in the owner portal, ACH deposits, and a year-end 1099 without asking.
Switching takes about 40 minutes of your time.
- 1 · 5 minutes
Sign the agreement
- 2 · 10 minutes
Quick call with us
- 3 · 2 minutes
We notify your current manager
- 4 · 20 minutes
Fill out the intake forms
- 5 · On us
We collect keys and deposits and meet your residents
Meet Holly
The porch light is always on.
Holly is My Haven's AI assistant. She answers the phone and this website at any hour, in English or Spanish. She doesn't take a message and leave it for morning. She opens the work order, sends the right vendor, books the tour, and has a summary waiting for the team at 7:00 AM.
Holly, on the line
2:14 AM · Resident
“Water's coming through my kitchen ceiling.”
Shutoff walked through, work order opened, plumber on the way in 45 minutes.
Pricing
Four numbers. That's the whole fee schedule.
No setup surprises, no markup buried in a repair invoice. Rates start at 7.5% for owners with 4 or more units. Full-service management below; leasing-only packages are available too.
Monthly management
8%
charged only while the home is occupied
Leasing
$999
flat, due only once a lease is signed
Onboarding
$199
waived for active military, veterans, and first responders
Renewal
$199
per renewal
Included in full-service management
- Rental analysis and pricing
- Advertising on 20+ rental sites
- Professional photos and video
- Resident screening
- Lease drafting and signing
- Rent collection and on-time disbursement
- 24/7 maintenance line and vetted vendors
- Owner portal, monthly statements, year-end 1099
- Pet damage coverage up to $1,000
- Eviction cost coverage up to $1,000
- One point of contact
- Month-to-month agreement
Optional protection
Landlord Protection Plan, $59 a month: up to 12 weeks of delinquent rent, up to $5,000 in eviction costs, up to $35,000 for malicious damage.
Leasing only
Leasing only: 50% or 100% of one month's rent, depending on the package. Homes listed at $7,000 a month or more use a 50% leasing fee with white-glove marketing.
Guarantees
Promises with a dollar amount attached.
Resident guarantee
If a resident we place breaks the lease or is evicted during the first term, we re-lease the home at no cost to you.
Happiness guarantee
Your first message gets an answer from your point of contact within 24 business hours, or your next month of management is free.
Pet guarantee
We cover pet damage up to $1,000 beyond the deposit for any pet we screen and approve.
Fee guarantee
No leasing fee until a lease is signed, and management fees only while the home is occupied.
Eviction guarantee
If it comes to that, we cover legal and court costs up to $1,000, or up to $5,000 with the Landlord Protection Plan.
Satisfaction guarantee
Not happy with us? Cancel the management agreement with no cancellation fee.
Homes for rent
Open now across the metro.
15 homes from My Haven's live listings, as of October 5, 2026.
Available now
Available nowJefferson Park
2345 Clay Street, Unit 4
Denver · 1 bd · 1 ba · 611 sq ft
$1,500a month
Dogs, no cats
Available nowAurora
2618 South Xanadu Way, Unit A
Aurora · 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,153 sq ft
$1,999a month
Dogs, no cats
Available nowUptown
1640 North Downing Street, Unit 204
Denver · 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,225 sq ft
$2,049a month
Dogs, no cats
Available nowVirginia Village
6285 East Mississippi Avenue
Denver · 2 bd · 1 ba · 1,215 sq ft
$2,249a month
Cats and dogs
Available nowCherry Creek State Park
4232 South Blackhawk Circle, Unit 5C
Aurora · 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,468 sq ft
$2,300a month
Cats and dogs
Applications are $59 per adult. Every home includes the $39.95 monthly Resident Benefits Package. My Haven never leases through Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace and never asks for wire transfers or payment apps. Equal Housing Opportunity.
For residents
Home should be the easy part.
Everything lives in the resident portal, and Holly answers the phone and this site at any hour. The office is open Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM.
Is it an emergency?
Call 303-228-7800, day or night.
If anyone is in danger, call 911 first. Smell gas? Get out, then call 911 or Xcel Energy at 1-800-895-2999.
Emergency
Fire, flooding or a broken water pipe, sewage backing up into the home, a gas smell, a tree on the house, or no heat in freezing weather.
Can wait for the portal
A lockout (call a locksmith), a fridge or oven out, a utility shutoff, a water heater that stopped without leaking, or A/C out under 85 degrees.
Rent is due on the 1st. If it hasn't arrived by 11:59 PM on the 8th, a late fee of $50 or 5% of the rent, whichever is greater, applies.
In their words
Owners and residents, on the record.
4.9
Google, 48 reviews
A+
BBB, accredited since 2023
Excerpts from public Google reviews.
“They had a tenant moved in and settled into my property in less than 30 days from when I first reached out to them. David and Kristie have been extremely helpful and transparent throughout the entire process. As an Active Duty member stationed out of state, I truly appreciated that they waived my onboarding fee.”
Joe Z. · Owner, active-duty military
“Because we live overseas, we were looking for premium property management service, someone to handle everything for us and engage us only when necessary. David and Kristie have been incredible partners throughout the whole process and they have managed everything exactly how we needed.”
Jennifer O. · Owner, living overseas
“My Haven has been absolutely fantastic to rent from. I cannot recommend them enough to potential renters. Extremely fast reply to any inquiries, especially maintenance issues.”
Cliff M. · Resident
“My Haven did a great job of helping me get my place rent ready. This included new carpet, bathroom flooring and painting. After the work it only took one week to lease my condo.”
Mike R. · Owner
“Communication, transparency, and efficiency has been top notch and she helped us get approved and moved in quickly! Their portal and information given has been very helpful.”
Hannah K. · Resident
“They treat my unit as if it were their own, always staying on top of maintenance, tenant communication, and all the little details that give me complete peace of mind.”
Sam C. · Owner, out of state
About My Haven
Locally owned. Not a franchise.
Kristie and David started My Haven in Denver in 2023, after years of running thousands of rentals for bigger companies. Owners get the people who built it, not a call center. Residents get a home that's cared for.
Kristie Teawalt
Managing Broker, Head of Operations
In the business since 2007, focused on single-family homes. Before co-founding My Haven she was a VP overseeing more than 1,000 homes. Grew up in Pueblo. Broncos fan.
David Walton
Co-founder, Head of Sales and Marketing
In property management since 2006, from lease-ups and mixed-use buildings to rehabs, including more than 2,500 apartments on the West Coast. Has roots in Colorado.
Where we work
Long-term rentals across the Denver metro. Don't see your city? Ask; we're growing.
- Denver
- Aurora
- Lakewood
- Arvada
- Centennial
- Littleton
- Englewood
- Highlands Ranch
- Lone Tree
- Parker
- Greenwood Village
- Cherry Creek
- Wheat Ridge
- Golden
- Westminster
- Broomfield
- Northglenn
- Thornton
- Brighton
- Boulder
- Louisville
- Lafayette
- Superior
- Longmont
“Trust us like friends, depend on us like family.”
Free rental analysis
What would your home rent for?
You'll get what similar homes nearby are renting for, how fast they're leasing, and where rents are heading, then a short call with our managing broker to talk it through. No obligation.
Rather talk now? Call 303-228-7800. Holly picks up any time.